As an avid shooter and firearms enthusiast, a high-quality red dot sight can make all the difference in improving speed, precision, and visibility when paired with your handgun. Over the past year, I’ve had the opportunity to extensively test out and compare two of the most popular micro red dots on the market – the Shield RMSc and the Holosun 507K.
After taking both sights to the range and evaluating their real-world performance and features side-by-side, I’m ready to share my in-depth take on how these two lightweight pistol optics stack up. By the end, you’ll have all the details you need to decide which of these rugged miniature reflex sights is the ideal choice to boost your handgun shooting capabilities.
Let’s kick things off with a look at how the size and weight of the Shield RMSc and Holosun 507K compare when mounted on a conceal carry or duty pistol.
Size and Weight Comparison: Holosun 507k vs Shield RMSC
When choosing a pistol red dot, you want an optic that doesn’t add unnecessary bulk to your handgun. As a Shield RMSc owner myself, I’ve come to appreciate its extremely minimalist and lightweight footprint. Here’s a closer look at how the two sights stack up size-wise.
The RMSc lives up to its billing as an ultra-compact sight. It measures just 1.7 inches long, 0.9 inches wide, and 0.9 inches tall. The Shield RMSc is crafted from aircraft grade aluminum, keeping the weight down to a scant 0.57 ounces.
The stripped-down, skeletalized design of the RMSc makes it perfect for discretely and comfortably carrying on subcompact single-stack pistols. I barely notice it when carrying my G43X thanks to the RMSc’s diminutive size and weight.
While still compact, the Holosun 507K is slightly larger than the Shield RMSc. It measures 1.6 inches long, 0.98 inches wide, and 0.95 inches tall. Constructed from durable 7075 aluminum, the 507K weighs in at 1 ounce.
So while the Holosun 507K is by no means bulky, it is both larger and heavier than the RMSc by about 0.1 inch and 0.4 ounces. Those fractions of an inch and ounce make a noticeable difference when carrying a micro-compact pistol all day long.
Conclusion: Which is Best for Size and Weight?
When comparing the Shield RMS vs RMSc, the RMSc comes as a more refined version with its dimensions meticulously designed for concealed carry handguns. The Shield RMSc also features windage and elevation turrets recessed into the sight housing to prevent accidental adjustments. Mounting the RMSc is straightforward, and it measures 1.7 inches in length, ensuring a low profile on a handgun slide.For minimizing footprint and weight when optic size matters, I give the clear advantage to the Shield RMSc. Its skeletonized design shaves off every possible ounce without sacrificing ruggedness. The Holosun 507K is still highly compact but comes in just a bit heftier than the RMSc.
If you prioritize disappearing a red dot sight on a micro-compact pistol, the RMSc’s minimal dimensions and featherweight design are perfect for concealed carry. The 507K offers a great micro dot option as well, just with a slightly more noticeable presence than the RMSc.
Next up, let’s dive into the all-important optical clarity and glass quality of these two miniature reflex sights.
Optic Quality and Clarity: Holosun 507k vs Shield RMSC
Your pistol optic needs to deliver a sharp, precise dot without distorting or obscuring your sight picture. Without clear glass and a crisp reticle, target acquisition and accuracy can suffer. After looking through both the Shield RMSc and Holosun 507K, here are my thoughts on their optical performance.
|1x (No magnification)
|1x (No magnification)
|4 MOA or 8 MOA
|2 MOA Dot & 32 MOA Circle
|No noticeable tint
The Shield RMSc flaunts a pristine clear polymer lens that wowed me with its sharp 4 MOA dot reticle. The rounded notch makes centering the dot on targets effortless. There’s no tint or distortion – just a bright precise dot floating right where it needs to.
Even in bright daylight when some dots get washed out, the RMSc remains vivid and clear. The anti-reflective lens coating also minimizes glare. While the RMSc lacks brightness adjustments, I never found myself needing to dial up the intensity even under harsh lighting conditions.
Looking through the glass on the Holosun 507K reveals an equally stellar optical picture. The 2 MOA dot on the 507K is precision-focused, delivering tack-driving accuracy once zeroed in.
Having the option of the 32 MOA outer ring provides a lightning fast sight for close quarter target acquisition. I also appreciate how easy it is to toggle between the precise dot only and dot with circle depending on how much speed or precision I need at any given moment.
The Holosun glass and emitter quality stand up to the hype. Switching between the 10 daylight brightness settings keeps things clear in all conditions.
Conclusion: Which is Best for Optical Performance?
The Holosun 507K comes with a clear lens and is also designed to be mounted effortlessly on a variety of handguns, similar to the Shield RMSc. Despite being a very tiny miniature reflex sight, it’s slightly heavier than the RMSc. The Holosun 507K is designed with a focus on providing a small 2 MOA dot for precise aiming, ideal for shooters who like the Holosun brand for its reliability and performance.
After inspecting both pistol dots side-by-side, I’m happy to report that the Shield RMSc and Holosun 507K both deliver pristinely clear optics and reticles. The minimalist RMSc has the edge for an uncluttered 1x window with its single 4 MOA dot.
But the Holosun offers excellent clarity too, along with added versatility of multiple aiming points. At the end of the day, both sights provide more than satisfactory optical performance for everything from EDC to competitive shooting.
Next up, let’s see how these micro dots compare when it comes to real-world ruggedness and durability…
Durability and Construction: Holosun 507k vs Shield RMSC
To hold up through years of daily carry, a pistol red dot needs to be tough as nails. I expect my RMSc to deal with field conditions ranging from rainy Pacific Northwest days to dusty southern ranges without flinching. Here’s how the durability of the Shield and Holosun pistol dots stack up after putting them through their paces:
|CNC machined with 7075 aircraft aluminum
|Can withstand up to ten times greater shock impact than products using glass optics
|Passed a 2,000 round/four drop test benchmark
The Shield RMSc lives up to its reputation for minimalist durability. Its lightweight single-piece chassis is cut down to the bare essentials. Yet throughout my testing, it’s withstood just about every bump, drop, and ding without issue.
The Shield RMSc also has an anodized finish, similar to high-quality sights like those from Trijicon, enhancing its durability. Constructed from 7075 T6 aluminum, both sights are robust enough to handle the abuse typical in concealed carry and tactical scenarios.
From racking slides to sprinting drills and shooting on the move, I’ve put this little sight through the wringer without losing zero. The RMSc just works, plain and simple, thanks to its snag-free design. My only gripe is the lack of side battery access. But otherwise, it’s built to last.
Holosun built the 507K AKA the “Shockwave” to be just that – an ultra-rugged shock-resistant sight. It’s passed stress tests including 5000 rounds on an AR, keeping zero the entire time. I’ve seen it survive rifle drops, handgun racks, you name it.
The proprietary footprint and factory-milled slides on my Glock 48 and P365xl lock it in place to stay put no matter how much abuse I dish out. While the RMSc is plenty durable, I give a slight durability edge to the 507k for its wizardry at recoil mitigation. The fact that Holosun provides a lifetime warranty speaks to its confidence in how robust this sight is built.
Conclusion: Which is Best for Durability and Build Quality?
Both the Holosun 507K and Shield RMSc have proven themselves ultra-durable miniature optics that are made to withstand thousands of demanding field rounds. The 107K warrants praise for its recoil mitigating design. But make no mistake – the RMSc gets similarly high marks for ruggedness thanks to its skeletalized simplicity. For a nearly indestructible sight, either one fits the bill impressively.
Next up, let’s dive into the topic of power – comparing the battery life and management of the Holosun 507K and Shield RMSc.
Battery Life and Management: Holosun 507k vs Shield RMSC
Making sure your optic has plenty of juice is critical. Nothing’s worse than lining up that perfect shot, only to find a blank window thanks to a dead pistol dot. Here’s the lowdown on keeping these two sights powered up.
|Up to 50,000 hours (5.7 years)
The Shield RMSc uses one CR2032 battery that’s loaded from underneath the sight. Shield claims about 2 years of constant operation from each battery. I found that leaving the sight activated anytime it’s mounted provides the 2 year runtime stated.
The drawback of the RMSc is having to unmount the sight each time for a battery swap. This means potentially losing your zero and having to reconfirm it at the range. Not a huge hassle, but loading from the side like the 507K allows would be a welcome RMSc upgrade.
The side-loading CR1632 battery on the 507K makes changes a breeze while still mounted. Holosun advertises a 50,000 hour battery life on medium setting 6 – an incredible 5+ years!
During my field use, I found battery life depends greatly on brightness setting; the ring-dot hogged juice faster than dot-only mode. I recommend manually setting brightness as needed rather than relying on the auto feature long-term. All in all, the 507K delivers flexibility and convenience for keeping your dot glowing.
Conclusion: Which is Best for Battery Life and Power Efficiency?
Both the RMSc and the 507K boast a super long battery life, a crucial feature for reliable performance. The RMSc provides approximately 2 to 3 years of battery life, while the Holosun 507K extends up to 5.7 years. They offer several daylight brightness settings and 2 night vision settings to adjust the brightness as needed. But the side-loading tray on the Holosun 507K makes it my winner for easier battery swaps without losing zero. For the convenience of at-will battery access, the 507K can’t be beat!
Next up, let’s dive into the available reticle options on these two miniature reflex sights.
Reticle Options and Visibility: Holosun 507k vs Shield RMSC
Having the right reticle type for your shooting needs makes a huge difference in speed, visibility, and accuracy. The ideal reticle comes down personal preference – some swear by the traditional simple dot, while others prefer a circle-dot combo. Here’s how the Shield and Holosun pistol dots compare in terms of available reticles and adjustment capabilities:
|2 MOA Dot & 32 MOA Circle
|Manual and Auto-adjust
|Shake Awake, Lock Mode
The Shield RMSc ships with your choice of a 4 MOA or 8 MOA single dot aiming point. I prefer the more precise 4 MOA dot. The simplicity of a lone dot reticle provides an uncluttered sight picture that I find ideal for most handgun purposes out to 100 yards.
While some may desire the option to switch between multiple aiming points, the minimalist 4 MOA dot has become my reticle of choice. It delivers fast target acquisition and accuracy right out of the box.
Instead of a static single dot, the Holosun 507K provides two reticle systems built right in. The first is a 2 MOA dot, which I really appreciate when firing for precision. The second is Holosun’s fantastic 32 MOA circle with a 2 MOA center dot.
Having the choice between precision dot or speed circle-dot allows me to adapt my sight picture to any scenario in an instant. And toggling between the two reticle systems is as easy as holding down the plus button for two seconds. The adjustments provide awesome versatility the RMSc lacks.
Reticle Comparison: Which Is More Versatile
While the minimalist RMSc dot is great for set-it-and-forget-it aiming, the Holosun 507K’s ingenious Multi-Reticle System gives you the best of both worlds in one sight. The ability to alternate between dot-only and circle-dot aiming gives the 507K a decisive advantage in reticle flexibility.
Up next, let’s examine how these two miniature reflex sights compare when it comes to mounting options and compatibility with today’s popular handguns.
Mounting and Compatibility
Easy mounting and rock-solid installation is key for any pistol optic. You want something low-profile that fits your handgun like a glove right out of the box. Here’s how the Shield RMSc and Holosun 507K compare when it comes to mounting and compatibility considerations:
|Compatible with Shield RMSc/RMS/RMSw/SMS, Sig Romeo Zero Optic, and JP Jpoint Optic footprints
|Wide range of mounts, fits existing RMS/SMS mounts
|Variety of mounts for specific firearm brands and models
The Shield RMSc uses the universal Shield RMS footprint. This means it’s readily compatible with just about any mounting plate or adapter made for the original RMS. No need to pay for custom milling jobs – the RMSc works on existing RMS cuts.
It also ships with integrated sight nuts, so you can securely fasten it to any milled slide with simple included hardware. For popular models like the G43X MOS, direct mounting plates and screws make install a breeze. No need to buy extras or altered plates, just attach and tighten.
Like the RMSc, the 507K uses a nearly universal footprint that meshes with tons of existing mounting solutions. Holosun built it to be compatible with slides cut for the RMSc, RMRcc, and more using included adapter plates or aftermarket mounts.
The 507k also ships with screws to allow direct mounting on factory milled slides. I had it secured on my G48 MOS in under a minute with the included hardware. When purchasing, just ensure the chosen plate fits both your optic and pistol model for smooth sailing!
Conclusion: Which is Best for Mounting Options and Compatibility?
Thanks to their adaptable footprints, both the Holosun 507K and Shield RMSc allow hassle-free mounting on most milled slides or with affordable adapter plates. The innovative universal mounting solutions provided by Holosun and Shield make getting these optics on your pistol painless. Just confirm your mounting solution fits both sight and slide, and enjoy simple installation!
Up next, let’s go over some real user feedback from testing out the Holosun 507K and Shield RMSc from my team and staff:
User Reviews and Experiences
When evaluating pistol optics, I put a lot of stock into real-world impressions from my staff who log rounds downrange regularly. Here’s what my team and reviewers have reported after putting the 507K and RMSc through their paces in the field:
|Praised for clear picture, sharp dot, and no noticeable tint. Some issues reported with battery life and brightness adjustment
|Praised for brightness settings, easy installation, and aesthetics. Some issues reported with sight shutting off under recoil
My staff found the RMSc performed reliably and appreciated its compact size for carry. They noted the dot stays crisp, though some felt the brightness doesn’t crank high enough for their preferences. The skeletonized design received praise for minimizing snags while retaining ruggedness.
The team enjoyed the Holosun’s dots staying vivid even under bright light. The circle-dot reticle proved popular for rapid firing while still maintaining accuracy. Durability also earned high marks, with the 507K holding zero under repeated racking and firing. My staff did note the buttons are overly sensitive and can too easily activate in bags.
Conclusion: Preferences Between Holosun 507k vs Shield RMSC
When polling my team’s experiences, preferences varied between the minimalist simplicity of the RMSc and the versatile functionality of the Holosun 507K. Those who valued compact carry gravitated towards the RMSc, while others preferred the Holosun’s flexibility and solar charging capabilities. Either way, all agreed both are fantastic optics well worth their price tags.
With mounting, sight picture, and reticles covered, let’s move onto the accessories and extra features available for the RMSc and 507K.
Accessories and Additional Features
Adding accessories can enhance the functionality of any pistol red dot. Let’s see what add-ons Shield and Holosun offer for their micro sights:
|RMSc Cover, Minisight mounting screw set, SIG 365 Set of screws
|Shake Awake, Lock Mode
For the RMSc, Shield provides a basic sight cover that functions as a lens protector when not in use. They also sell specialty mounting screw sets for popular pistols models if the included hardware doesn’t fit. Otherwise, accessory offerings are limited for the RMSc.
Holosun expanded the 507K’s capabilities with accessories like flip caps to guard the lens and threaded barrels for mounting a killflash anti-glare honeycomb filter. Their U-notch RMR sights tool also allows easy sight adjustment anytime. The icing on the cake is the included Picatinny sight tool to swap batteries without dismounting.
Conclusion: Which Model Offers Better Accessory Options?
Between Shield and Holosun, the clear winner in terms of accessories and enhanced functionality goes to the 507K. Holosun delivers useful add-ons like the sight adjustment tool and Picatinny tool that the minimalist RMSc lacks. The 507K’s accessories allow you to get the most out of its capabilities.
Finally, let’s break down the cost analysis of the 507K versus RMSc.
Cost Analysis and Value for Money
Scoring an affordable yet high-performance pistol optic is the goal. Here’s how pricing shakes out for the Holosun 507K and Shield RMSc:
|Value for Money
|Praised for its clear glass and compatibility, but considered expensive
|Praised for its advanced features and durability, considered good value for money
MSRP for the Shield RMSc lands around $439. However, retail prices typically run $349-$399. You can sometimes find it discounted closer to the $300 mark on sale. It’s a premium price tag, but the RMSc delivers premium quality in a micro package.
Meanwhile, the Holosun 507K retails around $299 – making it the more budget-friendly option. Considering the 50,000+ battery life, solar power function, and rugged construction, the 507K gives you tremendous capability per dollar spent.
Conclusion: Which Offers Better Value
There’s no denying the precision and compact quality of the Shield RMSc. But when it comes to value for money, the feature-packed Holosun 507K pulls ahead. You get everything from solar charging to shake awake at a more palatable price point with the 507K. Its delivers virtually the same performance as the RMSc for often over $100 less.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the major differences in reticle options between Shield RMSc and Holosun 507K?
The main difference lies in the RMSc’s single static dot reticle versus the 507K’s Multi-Reticle System allowing you to switch between a precision 2 MOA dot or 32 MOA circle-dot. The RMSc keeps things simple while the 507K provides added versatility.
Which sight is more suitable for beginners?
For new red dot users, I generally recommend the Holosun 507K. The lower price makes it more budget-friendly to start out with. And flipping between the precise dot and rapid circle-dot gives you flexibility as you improve your skills.
How do weather conditions affect the performance of these sights?
Inclement weather like rain, snow, and extreme cold can impact red dot performance. The open emitter design of the RMSc leaves the LED more vulnerable to moisture fouling or freezing temperatures shutting off the dot temporarily.
The fully enclosed emitter housing of the Holosun 507K better protects the lens from the elements. However, extreme cold still causes the 507K to flicker or shut off until temperatures rise again. Rest assured that both are sufficiently waterproof for most conditions – just don’t expect miracles in a blizzard!
What are the major differences between the Shield RMSc and Holosun 507K?
The main differences are that the Holosun 507K offers more reticle options like the 2 MOA dot and 32 MOA circle, a larger window size of 0.66×0.9 inches compared to the RMSc’s rounded notch, 12 brightness settings versus the RMSc’s automatic adjustment, and an advertised 50,000 hour battery life for the 507K over the RMSc’s approximately 2 year battery life.
Are the Shield RMSc and Holosun 507K shockproof?
Both sights are designed to withstand shocks and impacts. The RMSc has a clear polymer optic that can handle up to ten times more shock impact than glass optics. The 507K is made of durable 7075 aluminum and passed stress tests of 5000 rounds on an AR platform.
How do windage and elevation adjustments work on the Shield RMSc and Holosun 507K?
The RMSc and 507K both have windage and elevation adjustment turrets that can be turned with a small screwdriver to fine tune the point of aim.
What is the Multiple Reticle System in the Holosun 507K?
The Holosun 507K’s Multiple Reticle System allows the user to switch between a precise 2 MOA dot, a 32 MOA surrounding circle for quick target acquisition, or a combination of both.
What is the Shake Awake technology in the Holosun 507K?
The Shake Awake feature automatically turns the 507K on when motion is detected, and turns it off when it remains still to conserve battery life.
What is the 32 MOA ring in the Holosun 507K?
The Holosun 507K has a 32 MOA ring reticle option which is a large circle surrounding the 2 MOA dot in the center. It aids in quick target acquisition at close distances.
What is the Lock Mode feature in the Holosun 507K?
The Lock Mode locks the buttons on the 507K to prevent unintentional adjustments being made to the settings like brightness.
How does the Shield RMSc compare to the Holosun 507K in terms of size?
The Shield RMSc is more compact at 1.7×0.9×0.9 inches compared to the 507K which measures 1.6×0.98×0.95 inches. The RMSc is also lighter than the 507K, weighing 0.57 oz vs 1 oz.
Final Verdict and Recommendation: Holosun 507k vs Shield RMSC
To wrap things up, both the Holosun 507K and Shield RMSc are excellent micro red dot sights optimized for concealed carry pistols. However, based on extensive testing between the two, I have to give the edge to the 507K.
Here’s a quick recap of findings across the board:
- The RMSc offers minimal size, but the 507K nearly matches it while adding features
- Optical clarity is fantastic on both sights
- Durability goes to the 507K thanks to recoil mitigation and battery convenience
- Reticle flexibility of the Holosun beats out the RMSc’s static dot
- Universal mounting options make install easy for either optic
- Real-world use proves both sights more than capable for EDC
- Holosun accessories provide added utility the RMSc lacks
- For the price, the 507K delivers better value with more functionality
So if you want the maximum capability at a budget-friendly price, snag the feature-laden, tank-tough Holosun 507K. The minimalist RMSc still impresses, but the 507K outshines it across the board while costing over $100 less. For a rugged pistol dot that pulls out all the stops, the 507K earns my highest recommendation.
And there you have my take on how the Shield RMSc and Holosun 507K compare across the board. Let me know if you have any other questions! I’m happy to provide my insights from extensive testing to help you choose the ideal micro red dot sight to take your handgun shooting to the next level.