The accuracy of a shooter is often determined by both skill and the quality of their optics. In the case of the latter, the red dot sight takes precedence. This small but effective device has been used by shooters all around the world to improve their speed and accuracy. Red dots have been used in recreational shooting, competitive shooting, law enforcement, and military operations.
|
Our Top Choice
|
Runner Up
|
|
4.8
|
4.3
|
Today, I will be focusing on two of my favorite red dot optics: the Sig Romeo 1 and the Trijicon RMR. Each has its own set of merits, with differences lying in aspects like glass clarity, reticle functionality, and durability.
I use both sights, and I am ready to share my insights to aid you in determining the sight that best aligns with your shooting requirements.
Table of Contents
SIG Romeo 1 vs Trijicon RMR Optics: A Comparison
Each of these brands has distinctive advantages and disadvantages. By understanding these, you’ll be better positioned to make a well-informed choice. We’ll focus on key elements such as the clarity of the glass, adjustments to brightness, the level of eye comfort, durability, and power source to assess how these two options compare.
Technical Specifications of the SIG Romeo 1
Color: Black
Adjustment Increments: 1.0 MOA
Magnification: 1x
Objective lens diameter: 30 mm
Battery: One Lithium CR1632
Reticle: 3 MOA Red Dot
Length: 46.5 mm
Width: 31.7 mm
Height: 27.4 mm
Weight: 1.0 oz
Waterproofing: IPX 7
Illumination settings: 10 daytime / 2 night vision compatible
Total Elevation Travel: 100 MOA
Run time: 20,000 hours
Technical Specifications of the Trijicon RMR
Weight: 1.2 oz. (34.02g)
Magnification: 1x
Reticle Pattern: 3.25 MOA Dot
Reticle Color: Red
Illumination Source: LED
Power Source: 3V Lithium Battery
Battery Life: Over 4 years of continuous use
Adjustment: 1 MOA Per Click
Mount: RM33 Low Picatinny Rail Mount
Housing Material: Forged Aluminum
Finish: Matte Black
SIG Romeo 1 vs Trijicon RMR Red Dot Sight: Which Is Better
Let’s take a closer look at these distinguishing characteristics to aid you in deciding which sight could best serve your requirements.
Quality
Both sights exhibit impressive design and performance. The SIG Romeo 1, constructed with lightweight aircraft-grade CNC aluminum housing and flaunting a multi-coated lens, is a testament to quality workmanship. This is matched by the forged aluminum body of the Trijicon RMR.
The Romeo 1 apart is its Megaview optical design, which grants a broad field of view. Similarly, the Trijicon RMR provides outstanding eye relief despite its compact design.
Each sight comes with impressive reticle functionality and brightness modifications, with the RMR boasting a broader range of brightness settings.
Durability
The Romeo 1, constructed from sturdy aircraft-grade CNC aluminum, strikes a perfect balance between lightness and durability. This combination of lightweight and robustness gives it a competitive edge. It is water resistant of up to 1 meter.
The Trijicon RMR is forged from rugged, shock-resistant, fog-resistant, and water-resistant aluminum. The housing is cleverly designed to deflect blows rather than absorb them. It’s built to last beyond its warranty period, proving its durability. When it comes to waterproofing, the RMR wins: it can be submerged in up to 20 meters of water.
While both sights are admirably robust, the Romeo 1’s clever use of aircraft-grade aluminum provides an ideal balance of strength and weight. This is quite ideal in most local ranges.
If you are shooting in mostly tough conditions, the RMR’s robust construction may be your best bet.
Lens Clarity
The multi-coated aspheric lens of the Romeo 1 provides superior light transmission with zero distortion, simplifying the task of target acquisition. Matching that feature is the RMR’s true-color, multi-coated lens, creating a wide-band light transmission for minimal change in target area color.
Both sights provide exceptional lens clarity, a factor that plays a vital role in precision and functionality.
Reticle
Depending on the model, the SIG Romeo 1 has a 3 or 6 MOA red dot with multiple brightness settings. This allows the shooter to clearly see the red dot under a full range of lighting conditions. The Romeo 1’s dot is the sharpest dot I’ve ever experienced in a red dot sight. It is generated by a solid-state, power-efficient LED.
The RMR uses a 3.5 MOA dot. Slightly larger than the SIG Romeo 1’s basic model, it is a perfect fit for swift target engagement, especially in close combat situations. A tritium-phosphor lamp lights up the reticle.
As a firearms instructor, I prefer the SIG Romeo 1’s extremely sharp dot. However, for general shooting, the RMR reflex sight works just fine.
Battery Life
The SIG Romeo 1 uses a CR1632 battery that powers up its electro optics. A full battery can power up the Romeo for 20,000 hours.
On the other hand, the Trijicon RMR relies on a CR2032 battery, a common type that is well-regarded for its long lifespan of 4 years.
While both sights have their merits, the RMR’s battery life seems to give it a slight lead.
Windage and Elevation Adjustments
The SIG Romeo 1 and the Trijicon RMR, like all other red dots, have windage and elevation adjustments.
Recoils, especially those of more powerful pistols, can inadvertently change the zero of the sight. The SIG Romeo 1 prevents this through its TruHold Lockless Zeroing System. The system uses twin adjustment springs that are designed to withstand handgun recoil. If the zero does change, the springs return the mechanism to zero in every shot.
The Trijicon RMR lacks this feature. But I haven’t experienced the RMR’s zero being affected by recoils and blows. I have yet to see its zeroing performance after a lot of abuse.
Both sights have tool-less windage and elevation adjustments, so you shouldn’t have any problem adjusting them on the field.
Brightness Levels
The Sig Romeo 1 showcases exceptional brightness with 10 daytime and 2 night-vision compatible settings. It also features Motion Activated Illumination (MOTAC) technology, which prolongs battery life. The system powers up the sight when it senses motion and powers down after a prolonged period of inactivity.
The Trijicon RMR has eight distinctive brightness settings, which can be adjusted manually or automatically. In automatic mode, the reticle’s brightness adjusts to the ambient lighting condition thanks to a sensitive sensor.
Discussing windage and elevation adjustments, each sight brings precision to the table. However, the Trijicon RMR takes it a notch higher with its audible click adjustments, offering a more tangible user experience. Its auto-brightness feature is also commendable.
Size and Weight
The Sig Romeo 1 boasts an impressively lightweight design, tipping the scales at a mere 1 oz., thanks to its aircraft-grade aluminum material. This feather-light weight could be a significant advantage during extended aiming periods.
The Trijicon RMR carries a bit more heft at 1.2 oz. but compensates with its superior windage and elevation adjustments.
Both sights are compact although the RMR’s smaller size could be more favorable if your rail space is at a premium.
Price
If you’re on a budget, you should consider the SIG Romeo 1. At USD 349, it gives you great quality for your money.
The Trijicon RMR, on the other hand, is at the higher end of the spectrum, cashing in at a whooping USD 731 on the Trijicon website. It’s quite expensive, but you also get excellent features.
Firearms Compatibility
The Sig Romeo 1 has a universal mounting rail. This makes it a breeze to install on the most common Picatinny and Weaver rails.
The Trijicon RMR is designed to cater to different requirements with its assortment of models. It’s not only compatible with the majority of mounts available, but it also includes a specialized mount dedicated to Glock models.
Both are versatile red dot sights designed for use with various firearms, including handguns, rifles, and shotguns. Here are some examples of the types of firearms that are commonly compatible with these optics:
Sig Romeo 1
- Sig Sauer P320 series
- Sig Sauer P226
- Sig Sauer P229
- Sig Sauer P220
- Various other pistols with compatible mounting options
Trijicon RMR
- Glock handguns (Various models, including Glock 17, Glock 19, etc.)
- Smith & Wesson M&P series (M&P9, M&P40, etc.)
- FN Herstal FNP and FNX series
- Heckler & Koch VP9 and P30
- Various other pistols and handguns with available adapter plates or mounting solutions
In addition to handguns, both the Sig Romeo 1 and Trijicon RMR are also used on rifles and shotguns. Some firearm manufacturers offer models with pre-cut slides or mounting options specifically designed to accommodate these red dot sights. Additionally, aftermarket adapter plates and mounts are available for many popular firearm models, allowing users to retrofit their existing firearms with these optics.
Conclusion
Deciding between the SIG Romeo 1 and the Trijicon RMR depends heavily on individual preferences and specific requirements. These red dot sights, both known for their exceptional durability, crystal clear lenses, and user-friendly reticles, offer unique advantages.I’m inclined to say that both these sights hold their ground well in the market, providing great value to the user. Personally, I’m a fan of the Trijicon RMR, but the price puts off many other shooters.
Note though that for all intents and purposes. both the SIG Romeo 1 and Trijicon RMR are excellent optics that can provide you with much needed speed and accuracy.
