How To Test the Durability of Top Red Dot Sights for Shooters

Chris G.

Curious about how to distinguish the best red dot sights from those that are just average? Learn how to test the sturdiness of these crucial shooting accessories.

This guide will teach you how to evaluate the red dot brands and models, measuring their endurance in rough conditions, their capacity to absorb the force of recoil, and their battery lifespan.

Let’s push forward and learn more about the endurance of top-quality red dot sights.

Key Features to Consider When Testing Red Dot Sight Durability

Your red dot is going to be subjected to a lot of abuse at the range, in the wilderness, or your tactical operations settings. Thus, when evaluating the durability of a red dot sight, consider the following key features:

  1. Construction Material: High-quality construction materials contribute to the overall durability of a red dot sight. Look for sights made from robust materials such as aircraft-grade aluminum, which provides strength without adding unnecessary weight.
  2. Waterproof and Shockproof Ratings: A red dot sight with a high IP (Ingress Protection) rating is more likely to withstand exposure to water, moisture, and shocks from recoil or impacts.
  3. Sealed Optics: Optics that are fully sealed and purged with inert gases such as nitrogen or argon prevent internal fogging and protect against environmental elements. Sealed optics contribute to the longevity of the sight. Ask or check if the openings, covers, and adjustment dials have rubber or silicone o-rings; these help prevent moisture from going inside the optic.
  4. Recoil Resistance: Consider the sight’s recoil resistance, especially if it will be mounted on a powerful firearm with significant recoil. A sight designed to handle recoil effectively ensures consistent performance over time.
  5. Lens Coating: Look for lenses with anti-scratch and anti-reflective coatings for added protection.
  6. Rugged Design: A rugged and robust design is essential for durability. Features such as reinforced housing, protective armor, and durable finishes contribute to the sight’s ability to withstand harsh conditions.
  7. Temperature Resistance:  A sight designed to operate in a wide temperature range is more versatile and reliable in various environmental conditions.
  8. Vibration Resistance: Vibration resistance is crucial for maintaining the sight’s zero, especially when subjected to repetitive recoil. A sight with effective shock absorption mechanisms ensures consistent accuracy.
  9. Lens Protection: Features like flip-up lens covers or recessed lenses help shield the optics from external elements, impacts, and scratches.
  10. Dust Resistance: A red dot sight with effective seals and housing design prevents dust and debris from entering the optics. Dust resistance is particularly important in arid or dusty environments.
  11. Mounting System Integrity: Choose a sight with a reliable and secure mounting system to prevent shifts or movement during use.
  12. Battery Compartment Design: The design of the battery compartment influences the sight’s resistance to moisture and environmental factors. Look for a well-sealed and accessible battery compartment. A bottom-mounted battery compartment protects the battery better than top-loading or side-loading compartments at the price of convenience.
  13. User Reviews and Field Tests: User reviews and field tests provide valuable insights into the real-world durability of a red dot sight. Feedback from users who have used the sight in different conditions can help assess its robustness.

How to Perform a Durability Test on Red Dot Sights

holding a red dot

The only way to know how durable your red dot is, is to do durability tests on it. That means subjecting the optic to various conditions and scenarios to assess its ability to withstand environmental factors, recoil, and other potential stressors. These tests can be done while actually using the sight.

Before doing any test or before using the sight, familiarize yourself with the manufacturer’s guidelines for the specific red dot sight model. This information will provide insights into the recommended operating conditions, limitations, and any specific testing procedures suggested by the manufacturer. Do not exceed the limitations as specified by the manufacturer.

Test Steps

  1. Water Resistance Test Simulate exposure to rain or wet conditions. Submerge the red dot sight in water for a predetermined duration, adhering to any water resistance ratings provided by the manufacturer. The sight should remain functional after the test.
  2. Shock and Impact Test: Subject the red dot sight to controlled impacts to simulate recoil and potential rough handling. This can involve dropping the sight from a specified height onto a hard surface. Check for any damage or shifts in zero after each impact.
  3. Temperature Extremes Test: Place the red dot sight in environments with extreme temperatures, both high and low. This can involve exposure to a hot environment such as a heat chamber, and a cold environment such as a freezer. Monitor the sight’s performance at these temperatures.
  4. Vibration and Recoil Test: Mount the red dot sight on a firearm and fire a predetermined number of rounds to simulate recoil. This test assesses the sight’s ability to maintain zero and functionality under repeated recoil. Check for any signs of movement or damage to the sight’s internal components.
  5. Dust and Debris Test: Expose the red dot sight to a controlled environment with dust and debris, simulating conditions in arid or dusty environments. The sight’s seals and housing effectively prevent dust from going in. 
  6. Lens Scratch Resistance Test: Use abrasive materials to simulate potential scratches on the sight’s lenses. Evaluate the effectiveness of the lens coatings and the impact on optical clarity. Clean the lenses after the test and check for any permanent damage.
  7. Battery Compartment Seal Test: Check the effectiveness of the battery compartment seal by exposing the red dot sight to a wet environment. Ensure that the battery compartment remains dry, preventing moisture from affecting the sight’s electronics.
  8. Adjustment Mechanism Test: Test the windage and elevation adjustment mechanisms by making intentional adjustments and returning the sight to its original zero. Evaluate the repeatability and reliability of the adjustment controls.

Post-Test Evaluation

  1. Inspect for Damage: Thoroughly inspect the red dot sight for any visible damage, shifts, or signs of wear. Pay attention to the housing, lenses, controls, and mounting system.
  2. Functional Checks: Perform functional checks on the sight, including reticle illumination, adjustment controls, and overall operability. Make sure the sight remains reliable and consistent in its performance.
  3. Zero Retention Check: Confirm that the red dot sight retains its zero after exposure to various tests. If there is any deviation in zero, assess the cause and determine if adjustments are needed.
  4. Documentation: Document the results of each test, including any observations, issues encountered, and the overall performance of the red dot sight. This documentation can be useful for future reference and comparisons.

Important Notes

  • Safety First: Ensure that all safety precautions are followed during the durability test, especially when firing rounds for recoil and vibration testing.
  • Consult Manufacturer Guidelines: Throughout the test, refer to the manufacturer’s guidelines to ensure that the test procedures align with the recommended practices.
  • Repeatable Tests: If needed, repeat specific tests to validate the results and identify any inconsistencies.

How Do Manufacturers Evaluate the Durability of Their Red Dot Sights

checking on a red dot

Before manufacturers put out their red dot optics in the market, they perform rigorous quality tests to evaluate the durability of their red dot sights. The specific tools and processes can vary between manufacturers, but common testing methods include the following:

  1. Environmental Chambers: Environmental chambers simulate a range of conditions, including temperature extremes, humidity, and exposure to moisture. Red dot sights are placed in these chambers to assess their performance under different environmental stressors.
  2. Drop Test Machines: Drop test machines are designed to simulate accidental drops or impacts. Red dot sights are mounted onto these machines, and they undergo controlled drops from various heights and angles to evaluate their resistance to impact.
  3. Recoil and Vibration Testing: To simulate the recoil experienced when mounted on firearms, manufacturers use recoil and vibration testing machines. These machines replicate the forces generated during firing, ensuring that the red dot sight can maintain zero and functionality under repeated recoil.
  4. Water Submersion Testing: Water submersion testing evaluates the water resistance of red dot sights. Sights may be submerged in water for a specific duration to assess their ability to withstand moisture and prevent internal damage.
  5. Lens Scratch Resistance Tests: Manufacturers use abrasive materials and testing equipment to evaluate the scratch resistance of lens coatings. This helps assess how well the optics can withstand potential scratches without compromising clarity.
  6. Corrosion Testing: Corrosion testing involves exposing red dot sights to harsh chemicals to assess their resistance to rust and other forms of corrosion. This is particularly important for sights used in humid or corrosive environments.
  7. Battery Life Testing: Red dot sights undergo battery life testing to ensure they meet the specified duration of continuous operation. This involves continuous use of the sight to evaluate its power efficiency and longevity.
  8. Adjustment Mechanism Testing: Adjustment mechanism testing assesses the windage and elevation controls of red dot sights. Manufacturers intentionally adjust the sights and then return them to their original zero to evaluate the repeatability and reliability of the adjustment mechanisms.
  9. Durability Testing Rigs: Custom-built testing rigs are often used to combine multiple stressors simultaneously. These rigs can subject red dot sights to a combination of environmental factors, shocks, vibrations, and other stressors to simulate real-world usage conditions.
  10. High-Speed Cameras: High-speed cameras are used to capture detailed footage during testing processes. This helps manufacturers analyze how red dot sights respond to various stressors, impacts, and movements.
  11. Computer-Aided Simulations: Some manufacturers use computer-aided simulations to model and predict how red dot sights will perform under different conditions. This allows for virtual testing before physical prototypes are subjected to rigorous testing.

Manufacturers follow industry standards and specifications for durability testing. The results of these tests are essential in determining whether a red dot sight meets the required performance standards before being released in the market. In addition, ongoing quality control and batch testing are often used to ensure consistency across production units.

Most Durable Red Dot Sights for Pistols and Rifles

Several red dot brands and models are known for their durability and reliability. 

Red Dot Sights for Pistols

  1. Trijicon RMR (Ruggedized Miniature Reflex)
    • Known for its rugged construction and reliability
    • Options include adjustable LED or dual-illuminated models
    • Designed for slide-mounted applications on handguns
  2. Holosun HS507C
    • Features a durable housing with a titanium hood
    • Solar fail-safe backup and Shake Awake technology
    • Suitable for both pistols and rifles
  3. Leupold DeltaPoint Pro
    • Sturdy aluminum housing with a DiamondCoat lens coating
    • Motion Sensor Technology for extended battery life
    • Offers a wide field of view
  4. Aimpoint Acro P-1
    • Features a rugged aluminum housing
    • Offers a large window for quick target acquisition

Red Dot Sights for Rifles

  1. Aimpoint PRO (Patrol Rifle Optic)
    • Built for professional use with a rugged design
    • Long battery life and always-on illumination
    • Compatible with magnifiers for increased versatility
  2. EOTech EXPS3
    • Known for its durability and reliability
    • Offers a wide field of view and holographic reticle
    • Designed for quick target acquisition
  3. Vortex Optics Viper PST Gen II
    • A versatile scope with a rugged and durable construction
    • Tactical-style turrets for easy adjustments
    • Illuminated reticle for low-light conditions
  4. Holosun HE510C-GR Elite
    • Features a durable titanium housing
    • Solar fail-safe and Shake Awake technology
    • Multiple reticle options for versatility
  5. Trijicon ACOG (Advanced Combat Optical Gunsight)
    • Built for combat applications with a rugged design
    • Uses a fixed magnification lens
    • Known for its durability in harsh environments
  6. Vortex Optics Crossfire Red Dot Sight
    • Offers a durable and shockproof construction
    • Clear optics with multiple brightness settings
    • Affordable yet reliable option

Maintaining the Durability of Red Dot Sights

holding a brush and a red dot

Your red dot sight can be a sizeable investment. Make sure you preserve the strength, durability, and functioning of your red dot with proper care, maintenance, and adherence to best practices during installation and use. 

  1. Proper Installation: Follow the manufacturer’s guidelines and instructions when installing the red dot sight on your firearm. The mounting hardware should be secure and the sight should be correctly aligned with the bore axis.
  2. Use High-Quality Mounting Accessories: Invest in high-quality mounting accessories such as mounts and risers to ensure a secure and stable attachment to your firearm. Quality mounting hardware significantly contributes to the overall durability of the sight.
  3. Regularly Check and Tighten Screws: Periodically inspect all screws and fasteners to ensure they are tight. Vibration from recoil can cause screws to loosen over time, leading to shifts in zero and potential damage to the sight.
  4. Protective Lens Covers: Use lens covers to protect the optics from scratches, debris, and environmental elements when the red dot sight is not in use. These covers can significantly extend the life of the lenses.
  5. Keep Optics Clean: Regularly clean the lenses using manufacturer-approved lens cleaning solutions and microfiber cloths. Avoid using abrasive materials that could scratch the lens coatings.
  6. Replace Batteries Proactively: Monitor the battery life of your red dot sight and replace batteries proactively. Regularly check the condition of the battery compartment seals to prevent moisture ingress.
  7. Avoid Overexposure to Extreme Conditions: Avoid prolonged exposure to extreme temperatures, excessive moisture, or corrosive environments when possible.
  8. Use Protective Shrouds or Hoods: Some red dot sights come with protective shrouds or hoods. Use these accessories to protect the sight from impacts, scratches, and debris, especially during storage or transport.
  9. Avoid Dropping or Mishandling: Handle your firearm and red dot sight with care to prevent accidental drops or impacts. Mishandling can lead to damage to the sight’s internal components and affect its performance.
  10. Refer to the Manufacturer’s Guidelines: Always refer to the manufacturer’s guidelines and recommendations for care, maintenance, and usage. Following these guidelines will help maximize the durability and performance of your red dot sight.

Conclusion

Equipped with the know-how to assess the resilience of top red dot sights, you’re well on your way to choose the right red dot sight for you.

Consider the sight’s ability to withstand harsh conditions, its battery longevity, and its swiftness in target locating as crucial aspects.

With these factors in mind, you’re closer to selecting a sight that not only enhances your shooting skills but also stands the test of time.

About the author

The name's Chris. Just a regular dude who loves firearms. I've been shooting since I was a kid. My old man taught me the ropes.

I'll never forget the first time I missed an easy shot on a buck, thanks to a bum scope. The image was fuzzier than my dog's butt. After that, I got obsessed with understanding scopes. What makes the good ones tick and the bad ones trash. After a few years and a few thousand bucks, I learned what separates the winners from the losers. Once I had a good stockpile of knowledge, I launched this site.

Leave a Comment